All the Best Fire Island Theater Shows, Musicals and More

Theater shows on Fire Island

Find upcoming events in your neighborhood

On or off Broadway theater shows, listings of plays, musicals, opera, performance art, and so much more

Post an Event

Tuesday Dec. 30, 2025

72Artwork – TrumanVSIsrael copy

7:30 – 9 pm

Truman vs. Israel: Abzug and the Undressing of Truman

Theater

Theater at St. ClementsTheater District

Thursday Jan. 1, 2026

72Artwork – TrumanVSIsrael copy

7:30 – 9 pm

Truman vs. Israel: Abzug and the Undressing of Truman

Theater

Theater at St. ClementsTheater District

Friday Jan. 2, 2026

viewing party (55)

7:30 – 10 pm

“She Ate” Drag Dinner at Branded Saloon

Art
Comedy

Branded SaloonBrooklyn

72Artwork – TrumanVSIsrael copy

7:30 – 9 pm

Truman vs. Israel: Abzug and the Undressing of Truman

Theater

Theater at St. ClementsTheater District

8:30 – 10 pm

UG! Comedy Show

One and OneEast Village

Saturday Jan. 3, 2026

72Artwork – TrumanVSIsrael copy

3 – 4:30 pm

Truman vs. Israel: Abzug and the Undressing of Truman

Theater

Theater at St. ClementsTheater District

72Artwork – TrumanVSIsrael copy

7:30 – 9 pm

Truman vs. Israel: Abzug and the Undressing of Truman

Theater

Theater at St. ClementsTheater District

Sunday Jan. 4, 2026

GoldstarTodayTix2_480_720

3 – 5 pm

ApocaLIPSTICK

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

72Artwork – TrumanVSIsrael copy

3 – 4:30 pm

Truman vs. Israel: Abzug and the Undressing of Truman

Theater

Theater at St. ClementsTheater District

Friday Jan. 9, 2026

viewing party (55)

7:30 – 10 pm

“She Ate” Drag Dinner at Branded Saloon

Art
Comedy

Branded SaloonBrooklyn

8:30 – 10 pm

UG! Comedy Show

One and OneEast Village

Sunday Jan. 11, 2026

The Joyce Theater no people

2 – 3:30 pm

Compagnie Hervé KOUBI at The Joyce Theater

Ages: All
Art
Community
Family

The Joyce TheaterChelsea

GoldstarTodayTix2_480_720

3 – 5 pm

ApocaLIPSTICK

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

Friday Jan. 16, 2026

8:30 – 10 pm

UG! Comedy Show

One and OneEast Village

Sunday Jan. 18, 2026

GoldstarTodayTix2_480_720

3 – 5 pm

ApocaLIPSTICK

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

Friday Jan. 23, 2026

8:30 – 10 pm

UG! Comedy Show

One and OneEast Village

Sunday Jan. 25, 2026

GoldstarTodayTix2_480_720

3 – 5 pm

ApocaLIPSTICK

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

Friday Jan. 30, 2026

8:30 – 10 pm

UG! Comedy Show

One and OneEast Village

Sunday Feb. 1, 2026

GoldstarTodayTix2_480_720

3 – 5 pm

ApocaLIPSTICK

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

Friday Feb. 6, 2026

8:30 – 10 pm

UG! Comedy Show

One and OneEast Village

Sunday Feb. 8, 2026

GoldstarTodayTix2_480_720

3 – 5 pm

ApocaLIPSTICK

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

Friday Feb. 13, 2026

8:30 – 10 pm

UG! Comedy Show

One and OneEast Village

Sunday Feb. 15, 2026

GoldstarTodayTix2_480_720

3 – 5 pm

ApocaLIPSTICK

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

Friday Feb. 20, 2026

8:30 – 10 pm

UG! Comedy Show

One and OneEast Village

+ Export Events

More from Around NYC

A Rosedale man has been identified as the victim who was gunned down in a Jamaica Parking lot on Sunday night. The suspect remains at large, according to the NYPD.

Rosedale man identified as victim who was shot to death in Jamaica parking lot: NYPD

Zohran Mamdani speaks

NYC Mayor’s Race: Mamdani pushes FIFA to put ‘Game Over Greed,’ stop predatory ticket sales and keep World Cup seats affordable

Ane Dahl Torp, Ella Overbye, and Anne Marit Jacobsen in “Dreams (Sex Love)."

‘Dreams (Sex Love)’ concludes ‘Love Sex Dreams’ trilogy with a sapphic coming-of-age tale

groundbreaking brownsville arts and culture apartments

Construction begins on Brownsville Arts and Culture Apartments, set to open in 2027