All the Best Fire Island Theater Shows, Musicals and More

Theater shows on Fire Island

Find upcoming events in your neighborhood

On or off Broadway theater shows, listings of plays, musicals, opera, performance art, and so much more

Post an Event

Monday June 9, 2025

3 – 10 pm

Point Loma Play

Theater

Chain TheatreNYC

Lorca_poster_2025_web_v6

4 – 9 pm

Deconstructing Lorca / Desconstruyendo a Lorca theatrical multimedia festival.

La Nacional – Spanish Benevolent SocietyChelsea

CPNY-113 (1)

5:30 – 6:30 pm

Child’s Play NY Presents: Beetlejuice Jr

Ages: 5 – 12
Family
Theater

First Unitarian Congregational Society in BrooklynBrooklyn, NY

TEOAF Press Image

6:30 pm

The End of All Flesh

Theater

Magnet TheaterMidtown

Nine Moons OTS Image – No Silhouettes

7 – 9 pm

NINE MOONS, an original overture to Shakespeare’s Othello

Theater

Theater for the New CityEast Village

Tuesday June 10

VISIONS SUMMIT NYC 24 FILM-4

Noon – 6 pm

VISIONS Summit: NYC 2025

Museum of Modern ArtManhattan

3 – 10 pm

Point Loma Play

Theater

Chain TheatreNYC

1080×1080-CRACKED-OPEN_d39dd7

7 – 8:30 pm

CRACKED OPEN

3 – Florencia Cuenca and Company

7 – 9:30 pm

Real Women Have Curves: The Musical

Art
Comedy

James Earl Jones Theatre

Wednesday June 11

3 – Florencia Cuenca and Company

2 – 4:30 pm

Real Women Have Curves: The Musical

Art
Comedy

James Earl Jones Theatre

3 – 10 pm

Point Loma Play

Theater

Chain TheatreNYC

1080×1080-CRACKED-OPEN_d39dd7

7 – 8:30 pm

CRACKED OPEN

Point Loma Poster 1

7 – 8:30 pm

Point Loma

Theater

Chain TheatreMidtown

3 – Florencia Cuenca and Company

7:30 – 10 pm

Real Women Have Curves: The Musical

Art
Comedy

James Earl Jones Theatre

Thursday June 12

All day

Headshots Mini Sessions with Studio Day

Art
Beauty

A.MANO BrooklynBrooklyn

3 – 10 pm

Point Loma Play

Theater

Chain TheatreNYC

Three Musketeers

3 – 5 pm

Upper West Side’s Theater 86 Unveils World Premiere of a Thrilling New Three Musketeers Adaptation

Theater

1080×1080-CRACKED-OPEN_d39dd7

7 – 8:30 pm

CRACKED OPEN

3 – Florencia Cuenca and Company

7 – 9:30 pm

Real Women Have Curves: The Musical

Art
Comedy

James Earl Jones Theatre

Three Musketeers

7 – 9 pm

Upper West Side’s Theater 86 Unveils World Premiere of a Thrilling New Three Musketeers Adaptation

Theater

Three Musketeers

8 – 10 pm

Upper West Side’s Theater 86 Unveils World Premiere of a Thrilling New Three Musketeers Adaptation

Theater

8 – 8:15 pm

My Son’s a Queer (But What Can You Do?)

Ages: 9 and up
Art
Comedy
Family

New York City CenterMidtown Manhattan

NSA IMAGE

8:15 – 10 pm

NEVER SLEEP ALONE: A COMEDY DATING SHOW

The BoxLower East Side

#40sandsinglethepit_800x450

10:30 – 11:30 pm

#40sandsingle – The Secrets to Finding LOOOOVE!!! – An Edinburgh Fringe 2025 Preview!

The PITNYC

Friday June 13

All day

Headshots Mini Sessions with Studio Day

Art
Beauty

A.MANO BrooklynBrooklyn

IRREVOCABLE CONDITIONS (3)

2:30 – 4 pm

Irrevocable Conditions: A Play Repertoire For Pride

Inwood

3 – 10 pm

Point Loma Play

Theater

Chain TheatreNYC

IRREVOCABLE CONDITIONS (3)

6:30 – 8 pm

Irrevocable Conditions: A Play Repertoire For Pride

Inwood

father-anonymous-web-poster-final-1

7 pm

Father Anonymous

Theater

AMT TheatreManhattan

1080×1080-CRACKED-OPEN_d39dd7

7 – 8:30 pm

CRACKED OPEN

SIMONA-SMIRNOVA-photo-Pat-Simmons – Simona Smirnova

7 – 8 pm

Simona Smirnova: “Summertime”

Chelsea Table + StageChelsea

1_20250506_094508_0000

7 – 9 pm

Once Upon a Time in NYC

Theater

Reverie RoomUpper West Side

+ Export Events

More from Around NYC

anniversary day

The return of the Anniversary Day Parade: Our Neighborhood: The Way It Was

FILE PHOTO: U.S. President Donald Trump talks to the media next to Tesla CEO Elon Musk, with Tesla cars in the background, at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., March 11, 2025. REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque/File Photo

From bros to foes: how the unlikely Trump-Musk relationship imploded

JK_250203_0046-e1748903256918

Dr. Sara Glass, Thank You For Coming Out

grand army plaza arch ribbon cutting

Grand Army Plaza Arch emerges from two-year, $8.9M restoration