All the Best Fire Island Theater Shows, Musicals and More

Theater shows on Fire Island

Find events happening this weekend in your neighborhood

On or off Broadway theater shows, listings of plays, musicals, opera, performance art, and so much more

Post an Event

Friday Sep. 19, 2025

5 – 7:30 pm

Saint Ann’s and Fire Island Ministries Fall Festival

Saint Ann’s Episcopal ChurchSayville

Saturday Dec. 6

A Christmas Carol Newsday

7 – 9:30 pm

CM Performing Arts Presents: A Christmas Carol, the Musical

Theater

Cm Performing Arts CenterOakdale

+ Export Events

More from Around NYC

Mayor Eric Adams started the new school year on Sept. 4 at the new HBCU Early Prep High School in Jamaica, which opened its door for the first time to more than 100 ninth-graders.

Mayor Adams cuts ribbon at new HBCU Early Prep High School in Jamaica

Victim of harlem shooting with walker she used near where she was shot

Teen with firearm history arrested for using machine gun in stray-bullet slaying of Harlem grandmother

The Stonewall Community Foundation, seen here at the NYC Pride March in 2025, is stepping up to fund more than a dozen LGBTQ organizations as part of its Reclaiming Our Power initiative.

Stonewall Community Foundation rolls out grants for LGBTQ organizations under ‘Reclaiming Our Power’ initiative

NY: Rally to Save United Senior Center of Sunset Park

Crisis averted: United Senior Center of Sunset Park to reopen after $1M in city, state aid