All the Best Fire Island Theater Shows, Musicals and More

Theater shows on Fire Island

Find upcoming events in your neighborhood

On or off Broadway theater shows, listings of plays, musicals, opera, performance art, and so much more

Post an Event

Tuesday May 20, 2025

Carolyn Castiglia CHUCK

8 – 9:15 pm

CHUCK: A True Crime Comedy

The RATBrooklyn

Saturday May 24

12:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

2:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

Sunday May 25

12:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

2:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

Monday May 26

Too pale to leave the house? Is sunshine scary? (1080 x 1350 px) – 8

2 – 7 pm

The Spooky Social Club: Morbid Memorial Day

LittlefieldGowanus

Tuesday May 27

Annie – Child’s Play_107 Credit Hunter Canning

5 – 6 pm

Child’s Play NY Presents: Frozen Kids

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

First Unitarian Congregational Society in BrooklynBrooklyn, NY

Wednesday May 28

CPNY-113 (1)

5:30 – 6:30 pm

Child’s Play NY Presents: Beetlejuice Jr

Ages: 5 – 12
Family
Theater

First Unitarian Congregational Society in BrooklynBrooklyn, NY

Thursday May 29

Annie – Child’s Play_107 Credit Hunter Canning

5 – 6 pm

Child’s Play NY Presents: Frozen Kids

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

First Unitarian Congregational Society in BrooklynBrooklyn, NY

Annie – Child’s Play_107 Credit Hunter Canning

5 – 6 pm

Child’s Play NY Presents: Alliance Academy

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

First Unitarian Congregational Society in BrooklynBrooklyn, NY

Friday May 30

The RAT NYC – 1

9 – 10:30 pm

Sunset Diner: A New Play

Art
Theater

The RATBrooklyn

Saturday May 31

12:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

2:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

The Indeterminacy Festival

7 – 9 pm

The Indeterminacy Festival presents a preview of Into the Charmed Churned Circle

Dance
Music

Waterfront MuseumBrooklyn

Little Brooklyn photo – Erika Nusser

9 – 11:59 pm

Little Brooklyn Presents: LIVE From Coney Island A show that happens to be on a SATURDAY NIGHT

Theater

Sideshows by the SeashoreBrooklyn

Sunday June 1

12:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

2:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

Tuesday June 3

antigone

5:30 – 6:30 pm

Child’s Play NY presents: Hamlet

Ages: 5 – 12
Caribbean
Family
Theater

First Unitarian Congregational Society in BrooklynBrooklyn, NY

Friday June 6

8_faces_Event_listing

8 – 10:30 pm

The Eight Faces of Ellie Morrison: A New Play

Art
Music

148 Frost StreetBrooklyn

Saturday June 7

12:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

2:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

8_faces_Event_listing

8 – 10:30 pm

The Eight Faces of Ellie Morrison: A New Play

Art
Music

148 Frost StreetBrooklyn

Sunday June 8

Noon – 1 pm

Shadowboxing in Blue

Dance
Free

Haven BoxingBrooklyn

12:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

2:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

8_faces_Event_listing

3 – 5:30 pm

The Eight Faces of Ellie Morrison: A New Play

Art
Music

148 Frost StreetBrooklyn

Monday June 9

CPNY-113 (1)

5:30 – 6:30 pm

Child’s Play NY Presents: Beetlejuice Jr

Ages: 5 – 12
Family
Theater

First Unitarian Congregational Society in BrooklynBrooklyn, NY

Saturday June 14

12:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

2:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

Sunday June 15

12:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

2:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

Saturday June 21

12:30 pm

The Wizard of Oz

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

+ Export Events

More from Around NYC

Boris Production

Boris Production ends 30-year run with storewide closing sale in Forest Hills

Staten Island intersection

Bronx man killed by e-scooter driver while crossing Staten Island street

A picture depicting the late Pope Francis and Pope Leo XIV prior to his election is displayed as Bishop Edinson Edgardo Farfan Cordova speaks during a press conference, following the election of Pope Leo XIV, in Chiclayo, Peru, May 9, 2025.

Thoughts on popes, old and new — and their surprises on LGBTQ issues

cypress hills park shooting

Two teens shot in Cypress Hills park in Brooklyn’s third double shooting in as many days