All the Best Fire Island Theater Shows, Musicals and More

Theater shows on Fire Island

Find upcoming events in your neighborhood

On or off Broadway theater shows, listings of plays, musicals, opera, performance art, and so much more

Post an Event

Thursday Sep. 18, 2025

unnamed_f37df1

7 – 8:30 pm

Pinky Promise

Theater

Skinner Studio, Plays & Players TheatrePhiladelphia

BGWP Banner No Text 3200×1800

8 – 9 pm

Philly Fringe: “Be Good!” with Paulette

Art
Comedy

Asian Arts InitiativePhiladelphia

MacyJenTheCake216x9

8 – 10 pm

The Cake by Bekah Brunstetter opens September 12 at The Stagecrafters Theater

Stagecrafters TheaterPhiladelphia

Screen Shot 2025-08-31 at 1.28.48 PM

8 – 10 pm

Young, Queer, and Stupid

Asian Arts InitiativePhiladelphia

Friday Sep. 19

Attraction

1 – 2:30 pm

The Great Philadelphia Comedy Magic Walking Tour

Ages: 9 and up
Attractions
Comedy
Family

Philly Magic ToursPhiladelphia

Katherine Banning Chew dramatic tours FB event page

6:30 – 7:30 pm

An Unhappy Discord: A Dramatic Experience

ClivedenPhiladelphia

7 – 11 pm

Get You a Babe Who Can Do Both

Prism ArtsPhiladelphia

MacyJenTheCake216x9

8 – 10 pm

The Cake by Bekah Brunstetter opens September 12 at The Stagecrafters Theater

Stagecrafters TheaterPhiladelphia

Saturday Sep. 20

Katherine Banning Chew dramatic tours FB event page

Noon – 4 pm

An Unhappy Discord: A Dramatic Experience

ClivedenPhiladelphia

Attraction

1 – 2:30 pm

The Great Philadelphia Comedy Magic Walking Tour

Ages: 9 and up
Attractions
Comedy
Family

Philly Magic ToursPhiladelphia

LOTO Poster (13 x 19 in)

3:30 – 4:30 pm

Labyrinth of the Other

Icebox Project SpacePhiladelphia

MacyJenTheCake216x9

8 – 10 pm

The Cake by Bekah Brunstetter opens September 12 at The Stagecrafters Theater

Stagecrafters TheaterPhiladelphia

IMG_8DAE67D78E97-1

9 – 10 pm

The Presented

Studio 34 YogaPhiladelphia

Sam Rise_Credit Ray Bailey

9 – 11 pm

The Bearded Ladies Cabaret: The Layaway

Ages: All
Family
LGBTQ+
Music

The Wanamaker BuildingPhiladelphia

Sunday Sep. 21

Attraction

1 – 2:30 pm

The Great Philadelphia Comedy Magic Walking Tour

Ages: 9 and up
Attractions
Comedy
Family

Philly Magic ToursPhiladelphia

MacyJenTheCake216x9

2 – 4 pm

The Cake by Bekah Brunstetter opens September 12 at The Stagecrafters Theater

Stagecrafters TheaterPhiladelphia

Sam Rise_Credit Ray Bailey

3 – 5 pm

The Bearded Ladies Cabaret: The Layaway

Ages: All
Family
LGBTQ+
Music

The Wanamaker BuildingPhiladelphia

DSB_ActualPlay_1920x1080

8 pm

Dark Side Burlesque presents Actual Play: A D&D Podcast Burlesque Show

Dance
LGBTQ+

Franky Bradley’sPhiladelphia

Monday Sep. 22

Attraction

1 – 2:30 pm

The Great Philadelphia Comedy Magic Walking Tour

Ages: 9 and up
Attractions
Comedy
Family

Philly Magic ToursPhiladelphia

Wednesday Sep. 24

BGWP Banner No Text 3200×1800

5:30 – 6:30 pm

Philly Fringe: “Be Good!” with Paulette

Art
Comedy

Asian Arts InitiativePhiladelphia

acute exposure copy

7 – 8:30 pm

The Lemonade Stand presents Acute Exposure

Plays & Players TheatrePhiladelphia

Thursday Sep. 25

acute exposure copy

2 – 3:30 pm

The Lemonade Stand presents Acute Exposure

Plays & Players TheatrePhiladelphia

7 pm

Justin Willman: One for the Ages Tour

Ages: All
Family
Theater

Sportime Pickleball YorktownYorktown Heights

acute exposure copy

7 – 8:30 pm

The Lemonade Stand presents Acute Exposure

Plays & Players TheatrePhiladelphia

MacyJenTheCake216x9

8 – 10 pm

The Cake by Bekah Brunstetter opens September 12 at The Stagecrafters Theater

Stagecrafters TheaterPhiladelphia

Friday Sep. 26

Attraction

1 – 2:30 pm

The Great Philadelphia Comedy Magic Walking Tour

Ages: 9 and up
Attractions
Comedy
Family

Philly Magic ToursPhiladelphia

acute exposure copy

2 – 3:30 pm

The Lemonade Stand presents Acute Exposure

Plays & Players TheatrePhiladelphia

acute exposure copy

7 – 8:30 pm

The Lemonade Stand presents Acute Exposure

Plays & Players TheatrePhiladelphia

IMG_8DAE67D78E97-1

7:30 – 8:30 pm

The Presented

Studio 34 YogaPhiladelphia

MacyJenTheCake216x9

8 – 10 pm

The Cake by Bekah Brunstetter opens September 12 at The Stagecrafters Theater

Stagecrafters TheaterPhiladelphia

Saturday Sep. 27

Attraction

1 – 2:30 pm

The Great Philadelphia Comedy Magic Walking Tour

Ages: 9 and up
Attractions
Comedy
Family

Philly Magic ToursPhiladelphia

acute exposure copy

2 – 3:30 pm

The Lemonade Stand presents Acute Exposure

Plays & Players TheatrePhiladelphia

+ Export Events

More from Around NYC

ag1

Queens County Farm Museum to host 42nd Annual Agricultural Fair

nypd at the scene in front of crime scene tape in Brooklyn

Brooklyn man shot to death outside of home, person of interest in custody: NYPD

Erik Bottcher at his 2021 election night party at The Chelsea Bell at 316 Eighth Avenue.

Erik Bottcher is the voice we need in Congress

84th precinct stationhouse

84th Precinct: Teens arrested for allegedly stealing straphanger’s bag