All the Best Fire Island Theater Shows, Musicals and More

Theater shows on Fire Island

Find 2s0y9f in your neighborhood

On or off Broadway theater shows, listings of plays, musicals, opera, performance art, and so much more

Post an Event

Monday Aug. 18, 2025

1_7cc284

8 – 10 pm

“Pizza and a Play”, The Cherry Picked Playreading Series

Arts Project of Cherry Grove Community House & TheatreCherry Grove

Monday Aug. 25

1_7cc284

8 – 10 pm

“Pizza and a Play”, The Cherry Picked Playreading Series

Arts Project of Cherry Grove Community House & TheatreCherry Grove

Friday Sep. 19

5 – 7:30 pm

Saint Ann’s and Fire Island Ministries Fall Festival

Saint Ann’s Episcopal ChurchSayville

Saturday Dec. 6

A Christmas Carol Newsday

7 – 9:30 pm

CM Performing Arts Presents: A Christmas Carol, the Musical

Theater

Cm Performing Arts CenterOakdale

+ Export Events

More from Around NYC

expand

EHS awarded nearly $27.2 million to expand and modernize critical care services

K-Pop star Baekhyun perform at the Prudential Center

From South Korea to New Jersey: How a beloved arena became a K-Pop mecca for fans

Upon entering Oberon, patrons are greeted by a collection of mirrors and a sign introducing the space.

Oberon, a new queer cocktail bar, opens in Williamsburg

NY: NYCEDC celebrates Pier6 6 ground breaking

From rust to oasis: Pier 6 in Sunset Park breaks ground on $25M transformation into public green space